Tuesday, November 8, 2011
Grammar Time
My co-op and I have started the grammar unit for our classes. While most English teachers, along with their students, dread this part of the year, I am mildly enthusiastic about it. Fortunately, I am right in the middle of Transformational Grammar, so all of the concepts being taught are fresh in my head. More importantly, I have alternative methods to help the students understand traditional grammar concepts, particulary the functions of parts of speech, thanks to Shields. On Monday of this week, I watched my co-op teach noun functions to the first two periods, and I then taught the remaining classes. As I was watching him, I was frustrated to see that he was mutilating certain grammatical concepts, specifically indirect objects (he kept confusing them with objects of prepositions). Anyway, when I took over, I tried, perhaps unsuccessfully, to give the students a variety of methods to identify the functions, often resorting to what Shields has told us in class. I think the most motivating part of the lesson, for me, was that I was implementing more contemporary strategies within traditional grammar, and I felt as though I was rebeling against our schools' preposterous infatuation with traditionally taught grammar. I always imagined myself being one of the teachers who held contempt towards teaching grammar, but after Monday I feel confident that I might be able to succeed in this content area and helps students gain a practical appreciation for it as well.
Oh Greg! I had a similar experience: my co-op was teaching a couple of points that were inaccurate and when I gently explored a discussion of clarification, I was told that it was higher level thinking. Well, these kids are moving on to higher levels with misinformation, such as: the subject is always a noun and the first verb you come to is the predicate....yikes!!! Trans Gram makes it hard to witness this.
ReplyDeleteRight on Greg! The other day I we had a "correct this sentence" exercise for the Do Now and one of the corrections was the "us"/"we" distinction (when to use which one) and the kids had no idea what a direct object was. If I didn't have Trans Gram I would have been stumped to try and explain it, but I feel like it went pretty well. I'm actually looking forward to doing more grammar now.
ReplyDelete